Message 01428 [Homepage] [Navigation]
Thread: oxenT01363 Message: 17/59 L7 [In index]
[First in Thread] [Last in Thread] [Date Next] [Date Prev]
[Next in Thread] [Prev in Thread] [Next Thread] [Prev Thread]

Re: [ox-en] Re: OHA/ODA in English



Hi list!

Yesterday Stefan Merten wrote:
When we finally start to discuss this issue in English then I have a
language question. I'm not sure which word to use for the German
"Herrschaft". There is "domination" but to me this seems to focus very
much on the repressive aspects. Webster says:

  One entry found for domination.
  ...
  Date: 14th century
  1 : supremacy or preeminence over another
  2 : exercise of mastery or ruling power
  3 : exercise of preponderant, governing, or controlling influence
  4 plural : DOMINION 3

Indeed I think "dominion" which is listed as the plural form does fit
better. Webster says:

  ...
  Etymology: Middle English dominioun, from Middle French dominion,
  modification of Latin dominium, from dominus
  Date: 14th century
  1 : DOMAIN
  2 : supreme authority : SOVEREIGNTY
  3 plural : an order of angels -- see CELESTIAL HIERARCHY
  4 often capitalized : a self-governing nation of the Commonwealth of
    Nations other than the United Kingdom that acknowledges the British
    monarch as chief of state
  5 : absolute ownership
  synonym see POWER

I think this is better but I really don't know. I'll use it until I
learned something else. However, this ambivalence alone how much these
terms need clarification.

I checked further and I learned that the meaning of the German words
is simply not covered well by the English words. Ok, "dominion" seems
to be actually bad because it relates more to a territority. May be
"domination" is actually the best term. "Rulership" may be an
alternative.

This fact that the words do not overlap very well I consider a hint
that there might be cultural differences. Thus I consider it important
to have this discussion here.


						Mit Freien Grüßen

						Stefan

_______________________
http://www.oekonux.org/



Thread: oxenT01363 Message: 17/59 L7 [In index]
Message 01428 [Homepage] [Navigation]