I suggest you to open a project on Open Theory
(http://www.opentheory.org/). The software on which
is based OT is the
perfect one to make a collective detailed criticism
on a text.
2005/9/29, Michael Bouwens
<michelsub2003 yahoo.com>:
Dear Oekonux list members,
I was just wondering, since this is one of the
most
knowledgeable lists on peer production. Would
anyone
be interested in reading my manuscript, say
section by
section, and point out the errors, the criticisms,
etc...
If that were the case I could publish 2 sections
per
week, and try to respond to the comments? Of
course, I
do not want to monopolise this list and perhaps
there
are better ways?
For info, this is the table of contents:
Peer to Peer and Human Evolution 1
Table of Contents 1
0. Executive Summary 3
1. Introduction 5
1.A. What this essay is about 5
1.B. Some acknowledgments 8
2. P2P as the Technological Framework of Cognitive
Capitalism 8
2.1.A. Defining P2P as the relational dynamic of
distributed networks 8
2.1.B. The emergence of peer to peer as
technological
infrastructure 10
2.1.C. The construction of an alternative media
infrastructure 12
2.1.D. P2P as a global platform for autonomous
cooperation 17
2.2. Explaining the Emergence of P2P technology 20
2.3.A. Placing P2P in the context of the evolution
of
technology 20
2.3.B. P2P and Technological Determinism 21
3. P2P in the Economic Sphere 24
3.1.A. Peer production as a third mode of
production
24
3.1.B. The Communism of Capital, or, the
cooperative
nature of cognitive capitalism 28
3.1.C. The Hacker Ethic or 'work as play' 31
3.2 Explaining the Emergence of P2P Economics 33
3.2.A. Advantages of the free software/open
sources
production model 33
3.2.B. How far can peer production be extended? 36
3.3 Placing the P2P Era in an evolutionary
framework
38
3.3.A. The evolution of cooperation: from
neutrality
to synergetics 38
3.3.B. The Evolution of Collective Intelligence 42
3.3.C. Beyond Formalization, Institutionalization,
Commodification 46
3.3.D. The Evolution of Temporality: towards an
Integral Time 49
3.4 Placing P2P in an intersubjective typology 51
3.4.A. P2P, The Gift Economy and Communal
Shareholding
51
3.4.B. P2P and the Market 54
3.4.C. P2P and the Commons 56
3.4.D. Who rules? Cognitive capitalists, the
vectoral
class, or netocrats? 58
3.4.E. The emergence of a netarchy 60
4. P2P in the Political Sphere 64
4.1.A. The Alterglobalisation Movement 64
4.1.B. The 'Coordination' format 66
4.1.C. Peer Governance as a third mode of
governance
66
4.1.D. New conceptions of social and political
struggle 68
4.1.E. New lines of contention: Information
Commons
vs. New Enclosures 69
4.2.A. De-Monopolization of Power 72
4.2.B. Equality, Hierarchy, Freedom 73
4.3. Evolutionary Conceptions of Power and
Hierarchy
75
5. "Network Theory" or: The Discovery of P2P
principles in the Cosmic Sphere 79
5.1.A. Distributed networks and 'Small World'
theory
80
5.1.B. Equipotentiality vs. the Power Law 81
6. P2P in the Sphere of Culture and Self 83
6.1.A. A new articulation between the individual
and
the collective 83
6.1.B. Towards 'contributory' dialogues of
civilizations and religions 86
6.1.C. Participative Spirituality and the Critique
of
Spiritual Authoritarianism 87
6.1.D. Partnering with nature and the cosmos 88
6.1.E. The Emergence of Peer Circles 90
7. P2P and Social Change 91
7.1.A. Marginal trend or premise of new
civilization?
91
7.1.B. P2P, Postmodernity, Cognitive Capitalism:
within and beyond 94
7.1.C. Three scenarios of co-existence 96
7.1.D. Possible political strategies 97
Appendix 1: Methodology for Research and
Interpretation of P2P Theory 99
A. The use of a integral framework 99
B. The Sociology of Form and Fiske's
Intersubjective
Typology 102
Appendix 2. Launch of The Foundation for P2P
Alternatives 103
Appendix 3: The P2P Meme Map 104
Appendix 4: Reactions to the Essay: Kudo's
108
BIBLIOGRAPHY 111
__________________________________
Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005
http://mail.yahoo.com
_________________________________
Web-Site: http://www.oekonux.org/
Organization: http://www.oekonux.de/projekt/
Contact: projekt oekonux.de
--
ciao
magius
socialforge
un laboratorio di creazione sociale :: a social
creation lab
http://www.socialforge.net
_________________________________
Web-Site: http://www.oekonux.org/
Organization: http://www.oekonux.de/projekt/
Contact: projekt oekonux.de